All but once have we stayed somewhere other than the La Mer Hotel. This trip, we stayed two nights at the Dewey House and one night the La Mer. We've "thought" about staying elsewhere but just can't seem to make reservations any other place than here :)

The Dewey House, built in 1906, is the original home of philosopher and educator John Dewey and remained a private residence until approximately 10 years ago. La Mer Hotel, a Victorian conch house, was built in the early years of the 20th century. They are the only oceanfront bed and breakfasts in Key West. Both "houses" are part of the Southernmost Hotel Collection.